|
By Andrew Jacobs
© The New York Times
At a suburban Baltimore high school, 14 players on the boys'
varsity soccer team are suspended after dragging freshmen across
a muddy field and forcing them to stand against a, wall while
being whacked by soccer bails that are kicked at close range.
Two students are injured during the punting incident, one of
whom suffers a concussion.
On Long Island, the season opener for the Great Neck South High
School football team is forfeited after 10 players are suspended
for beating a freshman soccer player, leaving him severely bruised.
At a football camp on Staten Island, high school students from
New Jersey and Long Island are roughed up, paddled on their rear
ends and forced to box each other until they bleed.
For those who monitor violent hazing, incidents like these --
all of which occurred in the last year -- are disturbing evidence
that brutal initiation rites are no longer just the stuff of
college fraternities and military school barracks.
Although juvenile stunts and punishing endurance tests have
long been a part of high school athletics, educators and students
say the rituals have grown more vicious in recent years, mirroring
both the rise in reckless college hazing and the overall escalation
of violence in society.
A high school wrestling team in Trumbull, Conn., apparently
had a decades-long tradition of hazing, but this year, the ritual
drew the attention of the police after a 15-year-old team member's
bruises were noticed by his parents.
Over the span of a month, investigators said, the sophomore
had been spat on, hogtied, held inside a gymnasium locker, slammed
into walls and held down while other players forced the handle
of a plastic knife into his rectum. Three team members were arraigned
last week on adult charges, and five others have been charged
as juveniles.
To earlier generations, high school hazing meant scavenger hunts,
wearing beanies or fetching doughnuts for upperclassmen. But
these days, it is more likely to involve some form of humiliation
or physical abuse, say educators and law enforcement officials.
Although there are no statistics on high school hazing, a survey
of major newspapers across the country found 28 serious incidents
since the start of the school year, many involving beatings,
sexual assaults with objects or instances in which students were
restrained with duct tape. During the same period a year ago,
eight such incidents were reported.
"Hazing has changed from the goofy high jinks of the 50's
and 60's to something that is remarkably brutal and vicious," said
Gary Powell, a hazing expert in Cincinnati who writes a legal
newsletter for schools fraternities. "Like society itself,
it's become more violent."
Long cloaked in secrecy, the dark side of high school hazing
has only begun to emerge from the shadows. Once considered a
harmless, if unpleasant, part of high school team sports, hazing,
has also come to be seen through a different lens, especially
since the rash of school shootings has shown America how violent
its children can be.
Parents who might have once brushed off hazing rites as adolescent
foolery now see them as dangerous and sadistic bullying. In many
cases, it is parents, not students, who notify the authorities
after learning of a hazing incident. And school officials, sobered
by a spate of lawsuits that have found them liable for the behavior
of students have started to confront activity they may have ignored
in the past.
"The whole notion of kids just being kids, has changed," said
Douglas Fierberg, a lawyer in Washington who has represented
several high school students injured during hazing. "As
a result of high-profile incidents, parents have come to expect
that when they send their kids to school, they do so with the
understanding that the school will control and prevent wrongdoing."
Still, in dozens of interviews at local schools, many students
and even some coaches said that initiation rites -- from compulsory
head shavings to beatings that leave victims bloodied -- persist
in high school sports. Tom Howard, the athletic director at Farmingdale
High School on Long Island, said many coaches saw hazing as a
rite of passage, an essential part of becoming an athlete. "They
figure boys will be boys, and they just look the other way," he
said.
By and large, it is boys. Although hazing also occurs in girls'
athletics, the more brutal and sexually oriented assaults often
involve male contact sports like football and wrestling, experts
say.
School officials at Trumbull have denied any knowledge of the
wrestling team's hazing tradition. But the 1999 high school yearbook
refers to -- and celebrates -- some of the practices, as does
a team videotape made of a wrestling match. A lawyer for one
of the defendants said that hazing, in some form, dated back
at least 30 years.
Hank Nuwer, author of "High School Hazing," a book
for students published last month, said he first noticed violent
and sexual incidents in the 1980's. "Before that, the worst
of it involved players dressed in diapers or hot ointment in
jock straps," he said. "Now you see more cases of penetration
or extreme brutality, things that I think qualify as criminal
behavior."
While most of the pranks and horseplay at high schools tends
to be less hazardous than the well-publicized incidents of forced
fraternity-house drinking, they can be just as traumatizing,
say opponents of hazing. Such experiences, they add, also pave
the way for the more egregious initiation rites associated with
college sports and Greek organizations.
The harsher the hazing, the more likely an initiate will become
sadistic when his turn to haze comes, said Brian Rahill, of Columbus,
Ohio, who runs a Web site, Stophazing.org. "Hazing doesn't
bring people together," he said. "It only breeds animosity
and separates people."
In a national study published last summer by Alfred University,
42 percent of those who endured hazing in college said they were
also hazed in high school. Of the 2,000 athletes surveyed, 80
percent said they had been hazed in college.
"There is something terribly wrong with our society when
abuse becomes a means of bonding," said Dr. Nadine Hoover,
the study's principal investigator.
Mention the word hazing to high school athletes, and most will
deny it exists. But ask them how they usher new players into
their ranks, and they readily describe a tradition of practical
jokes and organized roughhousing intended to disgrace, degrade
and terrify.
Standing outside the locker room of North Babylon High School
on Long Island on Monday, members of the football team said their
annual "Freshman Friday" was a way of inducting younger
members into their "family." Jonathan Hines, 15, a
starting tackle for the Bulldogs, explained that with the locker
room lights shut off, freshmen players were roughed up, slapped
around and slammed into the lockers. They know we're playing," he
said.
But in the fall, after hitting one boy a little too forcefully
and making him cry, Jonathan said, he received a four-day suspension.
Asked if he regretted the episode, he said, "I was just
mad because I got suspended."
Beyond that spurt of violence each fall, newcomers to North
Babylon's football team are subjected to relatively mundane acts
of submission, like serving water to seniors or being ridiculed
at team dinners while they stand on tables and sing. Each season
the coaches warn against malicious behavior, the players said,
but the admonishment is generally ignored.
After individual acts of violence in school, concerns about
group brutality.
Vin Iovino, the athletic director at New Canaan High School
in Connecticut, said the school began cracking down on hazing
a few years ago after a student who was forced to carry a cinder
block all day with his arms in chains dropped the block on his
toe, breaking it.
That same year, he said, members of the girls' soccer team were
blindfolded, put on a train and told they were head to Grand
Central Terminal. The train, in fact, was going to a seedy station
in nearby Norwalk.
"No matter how mild the form of initiation, we feel that
it's demeaning to the kids and a distraction in the classroom," Mr.
Iovino said. Despite the ban on hazing, he said, the school newspaper
consistently runs editorials in objection, saying that initiation
rites build team unity.
Matt Flemming, 20, a former football and wrestling team captain
at Columbia High School in Maplewood, N.J., agreed that hazing
promoted team cohesion but said it also helped establish a pecking
order. "You have to pay your dues first," he said of
the freshmen. "They don't always realize who is boss."
To educators, however, the rise in sadistic hazing is further
proof that America has lost its bearings.
As family bonds weaken and relationships between adults and
children become more adversarial, teenagers are desperate for
inclusion in groups that help fill the void, educators say. And
without the guidance and input of adults, children invent initiation
rites that use abuse and humiliation as a means of proving loyalty
and self-worth. For examples, they only have to look to popular
culture or professional sports, where the hazing of rookie players
is celebrated in the media.
Dr. Rachel Lauer, a psychologist at Pace University who has
studied hazing, said many students were so eager to belong to
a group that they submitted to treatment they know is wrong. "In
addition to companionship and comfort, there's a certain amount
of prestige in belonging," she said. "And the harder
it is to get it in, the more prestigious it is."
The pressure to be included is so intense, most of those subjected
to hazing refuse to talk about it. "You rat out your teammates
and it's the end for you." said Mr. Nuwer, the author of "High
School Hazing."
Many students do not realize they have been victimized until
years later. Dr. Hoover of Alfred University said the number
of those who admitted to being hazed in college jumped markedly
between freshman and senior years.
"It often takes distance and experience for these kids
to realize that what happened to them was wrong," she said.
Those working to combat hazing say the best way to break the
cycle is by holding coaches and school officials accountable
while educating students about the dangers of such behavior.
Eileen Stevens, a Sayville, N.Y., mother whose son died of alcohol
poisoning during a hazing incident in college 22 years ago, said
the ideal place to start was in high schools, even middle schools,
where mythological yams about the glories of hazing are first
spun.
Over the years, Ms. Stevens has spoken to 40 high schools, usually
after a disruptive hazing incident. "It's become so deeply
rooted in our culture," she said. "So many kids glamorize
hazing, they almost look forward to it when they get to college."
Douglas E. Fierberg is a trial lawyer and partner
in the Washington, D.C. law firm of Bode & Grenier,
L.L.P. Mr.
Fierberg represents victims of hazing, personal injury and
other campus crimes, and serves as counsel for certain national
sororities which have committed to end hazing.
|